The Vulcans believed it was the Klingon homeworld, but on what basis? They might've inferred that from the fact that Qo'nos seemed to be their military headquarters, for example-and we know the Klingons have no bones about relocating their HQ. Or, "Qo'nos" in ENT might be nothing of the sort. It could simply be a different region of the planet, and the environmental damage incurred by Praxis' explosion might've changed the homeworld's climate. That's still awfully close, but it's important to note that the planet we see doesn't look much like Qo'nos in TNG. However, he was wrong about the ship's speed, and this "Qo'nos" could be 7.9 ly away. So, I might suggest that Archer was correct on the 4 day mission, since this is mentioned by another crewmember later on in the show. According to stardates, 15 weeks had passed since her launch, indicating a minimum of 5.2 ly travelled/week-270.4 c.Īlso, in "Detained," we learn that at the NX is 5.2 ly away from Archer (must be a new inside joke like "47"), and it picks him up in less than three days, indicating a speed of 1.73 ly/day. In "Civilization," we learn she's 78 ly away from Earth. I'd also compare those figures to the total distance the NX had travelled from Earth, as cited in other episodes. The guy even claimed that warp 4.4 was faster than warp 4.5. As I'm about to, I'll make an effort to find something in the show to rationalize it.įor instance, I'd first explore the possibilities that Archer was simply wrong about one or more figures, which would hardly be without precedent. ![]() If I am going to do it, though, it'd better be absolutely impossible to come up with an in-continuity explanation. No: I get it, and in many cases I'd very much like to do that (as I'm sure I've noted several times). I know I haven't yelled at or spoken crossly to you about that I was simply defending that approach, since you were all but convinced I didn't "get" the writing/inconsistencies route. Later, he says that 4.4 is 30 million km/sec., or 100 c, so yes, Qo'nos is still closer than Alpha Centauri. ![]() To nitpick, he said they could get from Neptune and back in 6 minutes at warp 4.5 (24 mil. Even if you are extremely liberal with your interpretation, that still makes the Klingon homeworld our next door neighbor. So that makes the trip to Qo'nos, if the trip is exactly 4 days, it is about ~5.23 trillion kilometers, or a shade over half a lightyear away. I don't recall the kilometers per second number, but Earth can never be more than ~4.54 billion kilometers from Earth, so at best that's ~15.13 million kilometers per second. Earlier in the episode, we got told precisely fast Warp 4 is in km/s, not to mention "Earth to Neptune in 5 minutes". It was stated to be a 4 day trip at Warp 4. In the first episode, they ended up going to the world, to drop off that Klingon and be grunted at by the Big Boss of the Klingons. On thing that has come up is naturally the location of the Klingon homeworld, Qo'nos. Gil Hamilton wrote:OK, on a different message board, there has be some discussion about the Trek show "Enterprise", specifically about contradictions in the show. *(naturally, I'd call it plain old bad writing, but whenever I evoke that, I get yelled at for not "suspending disbelief"). ![]() So what's up with that? It's canon, so you guys can't just throw it away, because of suspension of disbelief*. OK, on a different message board, there has be some discussion about the Trek show "Enterprise", specifically about contradictions in the show.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |